Restrictions: No geeks, nerds or dweebs as characters
Be sure to vote in the comments. If you have to vote 'anonymous', include your name or it won't count. Voting deadline: Wednesday night 11:59PM CST
| Ryan | Sean |
Join our Facebook Group:
Here
Monday, August 25, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
34 comments:
After watching each twice, I think Sean's has more replay value; however, I liked the cinematography, SNES-era RPG music, and risk of grossing people out demonstrated in Ryan's:
Vote: Ryan
Voter: Harry
Both were great. I liked that Ryan's obnoxious was not just the characters, but in the faux-drama -- great touch! Sean's is really funny, though, too, and I really hate improv, so I laughed. In the end, I vote Sean.
Oh wow. Ryan.
As a ComedySportz groupie/wannabe, Sean's characterization of improv bemused me greatly. Also, I really like commercial sketches.
On the other hand, the charaters of Dave and Sean are all-inclusively nerds, dorks, and geeks, so, as much as I hate to discount what I have deemed to be the funnier of the videos on a technical disqualification, Ryan has to get my vote.
I was going to vote for Sean, then Ryan started shaving his pubes which was brilliant. At that point I was going to vote for Ryan's but didn't like anything after "I can't be..." and changed my mind back to Sean. I then ate a bowl of cereal and watched them both again. Ryan gets my final vote.
These were both excellent this week. I agree with qualler about the delightful meta-obnoxiousness of the slow-mo razor falling. But I laughed out loud multiple times in my office while I watched Sean's. Every act was some variation of the Warsh-impersonating-Chris-Farley arm waggling. So, my vote goes to Sean.
P.S. Were those real pubes on the ground? Gross.
Wow, what a solid week! The nerd/dweeb/geek restriction is so subjective...you could say that both are eligible for disqualification. I thought for sure Ryan was going to get my vote, but then came... "Do you have the time?" "No!"
VOTE: SEAN.
I have to vote for Robert De Niro...I mean Sean. Rye's was good but should never involve him without clothes. Never.
If we had to vote on what was the most obnoxious, Rye would win. However, I'm voting on hilarity.
Vote: "I'm going skiing, Dave... HA HA!!"
Good videos this week but naked ryan induced vomit. I think the public needs to know if those were real pubes. The first 85% was good but the end failed. Plus something bugged me about the therapist. Sean's video was great and improv is super obnoxious. This mixed with terrible music and an amazing variety of cross fades and other transitions, Sean gets my vote.
-Dave
ps, mike is a total D-Bag.
I voted for sean's video because it was so much more entertaining than any of ryan's could ever be!
-Robin (Mrs. Perry) Pharis
My mom liked sean's video, haha:)
-Dave
Since I couldn't stomach through Ryan's entire video without throwing up a little in my mouth ... I vote Sean.
And because Robin Pharis is a saucy minx.
Sorry, Dave, but I can't be afraid to vote for truth, even with the feelings of complete strangers that I don't give a shit about on the line.
Sean
- Jessica
I agree with sam. Rye's made me throw up a little (although it was fantastically obnoxious). But Sean and Dave captured the true obnoxious essence of improv. Vote goes to Sean.
HAHAHA Kate, i liked them both, Sean's was almost so obnoxious it made me angry, Guess im gonna have to go with Ryan!
Ok, I have to say that Ryan is the better filmmaker, and that the pubes on the floor were surprising and surprisingly funny. Still, Sean pulled off what is without a doubt the funniest blue ball joke I have ever seen - maybe the funniest prop joke since Buster Keaton built a house in "One Week". http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gVJsmF5wAVU&feature=related
Vote: Sean
My name is Casey Butcher and I approve this message.
I vote for Sean because I hate prop humor so I felt this was true to the theme.
-Jim Pharis
I'm going with Ryan even though he stole my sunglasses move.
Jake
Mary
Ryan
Name: Sarah
Vote: Seaners
Ryan - obnoxious character, obnoxious slomo moment of truth.
Omar
Jeff
vote for Ryan
gross yet funny
Amy votes for Sean
I would have to say that Sean's was much more painful to watch and thus I am voting for Sean this week.
-Tess
Close one this week, but I gotta go with Sean.
Sean's
A kick to Ryan's crotch will get me every time.
Courtney
I agree with the comments thus far. Ryan's cinematography is clearly superior, and up until the slo-mo scene I thought I'd vote for him for sure. But aside from the pubes, the ending was one giant nose-dive. Sean's content was better, notwithstanding that super annoying freeze frame of Sam at the beginning. So amateurish. But nailed the improv bit. Final vote: Sean
-Schwei
I vote Sean because Ken told me to?
Amber :)
Gotta go Sean, man.
Asa
Brigitte votes Sean!!
My vote is for Sean
- Sue Pack (Still waiting for Sean in the laundry room ...)
I vote Sean too.
Allison
Post a Comment