Monday, June 2, 2008

Ryan vs Sean - Week #4

Common theme/element: Interview
Be sure to vote in the comments. If you have to vote 'anonymous', include your name or it won't count.











RyanSean

51 comments:

Unknown said...

Erin Kurtz
Vote: Ryan Day
Sean i thought you could have made the lamp voice more like the guy from unsolved mysteries. Would have been way cooler.

Unknown said...

Ryan - Mary

Jasper!!!!! said...

Terrible. You both should be ashamed. Ryan, stop pandering for votes with 'Mom dance!' and 'diarrhea' jokes - I've seen you be way more creative. The knife floating was good, though.
subtract 1 vote from both of your scores.

Food Hour said...

Looks like Tim only had something nice to say of mine. Tim's vote.

Anonymous said...

Ryan

Katie

Galen D'Attilio said...

Rye's was awful. Sean's was too long, but at least it was funny for the first 15-30 seconds.

Vote: Sean

Unknown said...

I don't know how rye's had anything to do with "Interview," but it probably does somehow. It was packed with more lols so it gets my vote.

Suggestion: dancing

Anonymous said...

Sean because Ryan's didn't have anything to do with interview.

Tyler

suggestion: dancing

Food Hour said...

interview: the questioning of a person

Who's to say the people in the beginning weren't be interviewed? It is a loose interpretation of the theme. Laughs are all that actually matter.

Way to sabotage yourself.

Dave Perry said...

I agree, lack of application to the overall theme. My point goes to Sean.

-Dave

Unknown said...

I too concur that Ryan's has nothing to do with an interview that and my vote clearly goes to Sean for the use of his sweet basement office.

KT and Tim! said...

sean for the lamp voice.

Ken Sykora said...

Rye by a landslide.

chegg said...

Sean for actually interviewing something

Dave said...

Hear ye hear ye, I vote for Sean

Omllem said...

Rye, it's clear you're using the premise of rules / themes so you can corner Sean's artistic integrity while you yourself damn well know you won't follow them so that you can corner the vote of the idiot.

Sean, you get my vote, for being funny AND relevant to the subject at hand.

--Alex C. Schaefer
Private Investigator

Anonymous said...

Way to sabotage yourself Rye!

-Anonymous

chris said...

Consider this two votes for Sean from Chris and Jess!

Jessica's Suggestion: A Haberdashery

Food Hour said...

For clarification:

The "interpret that as you will" addition to previous posts means that I am able to interpret the theme's direction however loosely I please, seeing as I chose it. As I interpret it, the people in the beginning of the video were being interviewed.

The point of the common theme is to give me, Sean, and voters something on which to begin. It is not meant to knock a video from contention (unless completely and utterly irrelevant).

Anyway, this is just for future videos. The reason we created the show was to vote for better comedy, not technicalities (again, unless absurdly straying).

Thanks for watching.

PS- Shut up Alex. I know the rules. I wrote them.

Anonymous said...

rrrryan!

-jeff j.

Anonymous said...

Name: Rosy
Vote: Ryan

Unknown said...

Mr. Day gets the win.

P. Arty said...

I vote for Sean because of diarrhea jokes.

This is Pat.

Suggestion: Red Carpet

Sean said...

Ryan is wrong up above. The suggestion is like a constraint. The episode should contain the theme or element, even if in passing.

Who decides if the element is present? The voters, not Ryan with some post hoc explanation.

Voters decide on best video to them based on whatever rubric they choose. Preferably they vote based on comedy or enjoyability. Spite votes, however, will occur..

Food Hour said...

You essentially said the same thing as me. I was merely trying to encourage votes based on the initial purpose of the show.

I do not disagree about the rule of theme constraint. I am stressing that there was always freedom of interpretation.

Spite away.

Anonymous said...

Name: Marisa
Vote: Ryan
Comments: The people in Ryan's video had better facial expressions. Sean, I'm sorry, but your lamp lost me at wizards and sorcerers.

Anonymous said...

Ryan!! Diarrhea is funny!

Anonymous said...

ryan's video because of the knife

-martin

Anonymous said...

blah blah blah ryan's was better and sean's wasn't funny.

i vote for ryan.

-amanda

The Jewish Dream said...

Sean, Sean, for the love of god, Sean!

Next theme suggestion: Bernoulli's principal of lift.

cwolf said...

I vote for Ryan because Sean gave me shit about the Red Wings.

Lynn said...

Name: Lynn
Vote: Sean

Diarrhea stopped being funny in 3rd grade. Sean's could have been shorter though. Still, I'm voting for Sean.

Ashley Meyer said...

Name: Ashley
Vote: Sean
Suggestion:
the lamp's voice was sort of cliche, but not as cliche as using diarrhea to try to make something funny. even the flying knife didn't redeem it.

Ashley Meyer said...

also, i think sean's could be enhanced by using different camera angles, maybe some sound effects or music, flashbacks, etc.

next week's theme ideas:
* tea
* the internet
* internet dating
* the color chartreuse
* pizza

KP said...

This one goes to Ryan. mostly because of the aggressive knife.

=kavi

Anonymous said...

Vote: Ryan

Ashley

Unknown said...

Ryan - although I thought the problem should have been funnier...like something that totally didn't matter

Sorry Sean...the lamp just didn't capture me.

Anonymous said...

Vote: Sean

Anonymous said...

vote - ryan

susan davis

Anonymous said...

Elise - Ryan

Anonymous said...

Vote: Ryan

Brian

Anonymous said...

Name: Sarah H.
Vote: Sean, my bro is hilarious!
Suggestion: andy samberg!!!

Unknown said...

Qualler
Vote: Sean (Ransom! Hilarious. I also love the widescreen presentation. And a touching hand-to-cord handshake that made me weep a little bit.)
Suggestion: Existentialism.

Jia said...

Vote: Sean, by far, because I actually loled. A lot.
Suggestion: Corn on the cob.

steph said...

steph
vote: Sean

Anonymous said...

sean!!

katie t

suggestion: disney charaters!

Anonymous said...

ryan

-heather

Anonymous said...

ryan!

-samantha

Anonymous said...

ryan day man!

---brian f

Anonymous said...

ryan, mate

love, tom

Anonymous said...

ryan

-nicole!